Skip to content
Pool Chemical Log

Chlorine Keeps Dropping Troubleshooter: Why Free Chlorine Won't Hold

Updated

Why won't my free chlorine hold?

You need a CYA (stabilizer) reading and a DPD free chlorine reading from the same sample. CDC lists swimmer waste, dirt and sunlight as the things that use chlorine up, and the tree sorts those from a stabilizer problem and from a bad test.

What does a CYA (stabilizer) test show?

Dichlor and trichlor both add CYA each time they are used, so a pool on those products may have more than you think.

Under 30 ppm, or none at all

Does the pool sit in direct sun for much of the day?

Yes, a lot of direct sun

Act now

Sunlight is burning off unprotected chlorine

PHTA's cyanuric acid bulletin says that without stabilizer in the water, bright sunlight can break down most of the chlorine in a pool within an hour. Michigan State University Extension's manual puts the loss at 97% in two hours of bright sun. Stabilizer slows this sharply, and PHTA gives 30 to 50 ppm as its ideal range when CYA is used.

What to do

  1. Add stabilizer so the reading lands in the 30 to 50 ppm range; the cyanuric acid calculator sizes the dose for your pool volume.
  2. Until then, test free chlorine at least twice a day, as CDC advises, and keep it at or above 1 ppm.
  3. Retest CYA 24 hours after adding it, which is when the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, tests a pool; granular stabilizer dissolves slowly.
No, it is shaded or indoors

Does free chlorine also fall overnight, when there is no sun on the water?

Yes, it falls overnight too

What does the water look like?

Look for cloudiness, a green tint, slime on walls and steps, and a sharp chemical smell. Then subtract free from total chlorine to get combined chlorine.

Cloudy, tinted green, or slimy on the walls

Act now

Algae or organic matter is using the chlorine

Michigan State University Extension's manual lists extra chlorine demand among the effects of algae, along with a turbid look and a clogged filter. A pool that loses chlorine overnight and looks cloudy or green is feeding that growth, and normal doses will not get ahead of it.

What to do

  1. Brush surfaces, then shock to the level the pool needs and keep the filter running until the water is clear.
  2. Retest free chlorine a few hours after dosing; if it has stayed up, the demand has been met.
  3. Check CYA too: the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says algae can need more chlorine or a lower CYA-to-chlorine ratio.
Clear, with a sharp smell, and combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm

Act now

Chlorine tied up as chloramines

When free chlorine meets ammonia and other nitrogen compounds from swimmers, it turns into chloramines. Michigan State University Extension's manual says they have less than 1% of the sanitizing power of free chlorine. Combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm is the level the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, says to act on.

What to do

  1. Shock to breakpoint: the pool shock calculator sizes a dose of 10 times the combined chlorine.
  2. Retest total and free chlorine afterward; the combined figure should drop toward zero.
  3. Shower before swimming and keep swimmers from urinating in the water, since the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists showering and not urinating in the water among the practices that reduce chloramine formation.
Clear and odorless, after heavy swimming, rain or leaves

Deal with it soon

A high chlorine demand from use or weather

CDC lists pee, sweat, dirt and sunlight among the things that reduce chlorine, and says to test more often when many people are using the pool. A swim party, a storm or a week of fallen leaves can use a day's chlorine in a few hours.

What to do

  1. Skim and vacuum out debris and empty the baskets, then raise free chlorine.
  2. Test again after the pool has been used, not just in the morning.
  3. If combined chlorine is above 0.4 ppm, shock to breakpoint.
Clear and odorless, with nothing unusual

Keep an eye on it

Check the test before blaming the water

With CYA in range, no algae and no smell, a falling reading may be the test. CDC says strips are less accurate than a DPD kit, and that above 10 ppm the reagent can bleach out and show a false low or zero. Michigan State University Extension's manual warns that old reagents and dirty tubes give unreliable results.

What to do

  1. Retest with a DPD kit, fresh reagents and a clean tube, from the same spot at the same time of day.
  2. If the color flashes and fades, dilute the sample with tap water and multiply the reading by the dilution.
  3. Record each reading in the log for a week; a pattern shows what a single result cannot.
Only through the day

Keep an eye on it

Daytime losses with CYA in range

Stabilizer slows the loss to sunlight but does not stop it, and temperature, swimmers and debris still use chlorine through the day. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists swimmer load, sunlight, temperature and the feeder's capacity as the things that set how high free chlorine should be kept.

What to do

  1. Test twice a day and note the readings in the log; a steady, predictable drop is chlorine being used, not chlorine disappearing.
  2. Aim for a free chlorine reading that leaves a margin above the minimum when the pool is busy and the sun is high.
  3. If the margin never lasts, check whether your feeder or generator can keep up; for equipment, consult the manufacturer's manual or a pool service technician.
30 to 90 ppm

Divide the CYA reading by the free chlorine reading. What do you get?

For example, CYA 60 and free chlorine 1.0 gives 60. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, treats a ratio above 45 as a hazard.

More than 45

Act now

CYA is too high for your chlorine level

Stabilizer holds most of a pool's chlorine in reserve, which also lowers the share that is active as hypochlorous acid. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, calls a CYA-to-free-chlorine ratio above 45 to 1 an imminent hazard, and its Annex, guidance for public pools, says free chlorine should rise in proportion as CYA rises.

What to do

  1. Raise free chlorine until CYA divided by chlorine is 45 or less; the cyanuric acid calculator shows the chlorine floor for your CYA reading.
  2. For a lasting fix, lower CYA: PHTA lists a partial drain and refill, extra backwashing and routine water replacement. Nothing you add removes it.
  3. Stop using trichlor or dichlor until CYA is back in range, because each adds more.
45 or less

Does free chlorine also fall overnight, when there is no sun on the water?

Yes, it falls overnight too

What does the water look like?

Look for cloudiness, a green tint, slime on walls and steps, and a sharp chemical smell. Then subtract free from total chlorine to get combined chlorine.

Cloudy, tinted green, or slimy on the walls

Act now

Algae or organic matter is using the chlorine

Michigan State University Extension's manual lists extra chlorine demand among the effects of algae, along with a turbid look and a clogged filter. A pool that loses chlorine overnight and looks cloudy or green is feeding that growth, and normal doses will not get ahead of it.

What to do

  1. Brush surfaces, then shock to the level the pool needs and keep the filter running until the water is clear.
  2. Retest free chlorine a few hours after dosing; if it has stayed up, the demand has been met.
  3. Check CYA too: the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says algae can need more chlorine or a lower CYA-to-chlorine ratio.
Clear, with a sharp smell, and combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm

Act now

Chlorine tied up as chloramines

When free chlorine meets ammonia and other nitrogen compounds from swimmers, it turns into chloramines. Michigan State University Extension's manual says they have less than 1% of the sanitizing power of free chlorine. Combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm is the level the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, says to act on.

What to do

  1. Shock to breakpoint: the pool shock calculator sizes a dose of 10 times the combined chlorine.
  2. Retest total and free chlorine afterward; the combined figure should drop toward zero.
  3. Shower before swimming and keep swimmers from urinating in the water, since the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists showering and not urinating in the water among the practices that reduce chloramine formation.
Clear and odorless, after heavy swimming, rain or leaves

Deal with it soon

A high chlorine demand from use or weather

CDC lists pee, sweat, dirt and sunlight among the things that reduce chlorine, and says to test more often when many people are using the pool. A swim party, a storm or a week of fallen leaves can use a day's chlorine in a few hours.

What to do

  1. Skim and vacuum out debris and empty the baskets, then raise free chlorine.
  2. Test again after the pool has been used, not just in the morning.
  3. If combined chlorine is above 0.4 ppm, shock to breakpoint.
Clear and odorless, with nothing unusual

Keep an eye on it

Check the test before blaming the water

With CYA in range, no algae and no smell, a falling reading may be the test. CDC says strips are less accurate than a DPD kit, and that above 10 ppm the reagent can bleach out and show a false low or zero. Michigan State University Extension's manual warns that old reagents and dirty tubes give unreliable results.

What to do

  1. Retest with a DPD kit, fresh reagents and a clean tube, from the same spot at the same time of day.
  2. If the color flashes and fades, dilute the sample with tap water and multiply the reading by the dilution.
  3. Record each reading in the log for a week; a pattern shows what a single result cannot.
Only through the day

Keep an eye on it

Daytime losses with CYA in range

Stabilizer slows the loss to sunlight but does not stop it, and temperature, swimmers and debris still use chlorine through the day. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists swimmer load, sunlight, temperature and the feeder's capacity as the things that set how high free chlorine should be kept.

What to do

  1. Test twice a day and note the readings in the log; a steady, predictable drop is chlorine being used, not chlorine disappearing.
  2. Aim for a free chlorine reading that leaves a margin above the minimum when the pool is busy and the sun is high.
  3. If the margin never lasts, check whether your feeder or generator can keep up; for equipment, consult the manufacturer's manual or a pool service technician.
Above 90 ppm

Deal with it soon

CYA is above the 90 ppm limit

PHTA says the stabilizer concentration should not exceed 100 ppm and that no extra protection was seen above it. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, keeps CYA at or below 90 ppm and orders a pool closed at 300 ppm or more. Past this point extra CYA only ties up more of your chlorine.

What to do

  1. Plan a partial drain and refill with fresh water; the cyanuric acid calculator shows what share to replace for the CYA you want.
  2. Until it is down, keep free chlorine high enough that CYA divided by free chlorine stays at or under 45.
  3. Switch to an unstabilized chlorine, such as liquid chlorine, while you bring CYA down.
I have not tested it

Deal with it soon

Get a CYA reading before changing anything

Stabilizer decides how fast sunlight takes chlorine, and how much chlorine the pool needs to stay safe, so every other step in a chlorine-loss problem depends on it. A pool supply store can test it, or you can use a CYA test kit.

What to do

  1. Test CYA, free chlorine and combined chlorine from the same sample, taken at least 18 inches below the surface and away from the return inlets, as the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, specifies for its samples.
  2. Return to this troubleshooter with the CYA reading.
  3. In the meantime, keep free chlorine at or above 2 ppm if the pool has had trichlor or dichlor; CDC raises the minimum from 1 to 2 ppm for a stabilized pool.

In short: Free chlorine that will not hold comes from sunlight on a pool with little CYA, CYA too high for the chlorine (the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, flags a ratio above 45 to 1), algae, chloramines, or a faulty test. CDC, PHTA and Michigan State University Extension supply the figures.

This troubleshooter narrows down likely causes from published guidance; it can't see or test your water. Retest before you add anything, follow the label on every product you use, and call a pool service technician or a licensed electrician for anything electrical, gas-fired or structural.

Get new tools by email

When we add a tool to Pool Chemical Log, we'll send you one short email. Nothing else.

This troubleshooter is for a pool owner who tops up chlorine and finds it gone again by the next test. It starts from the one reading that explains the most, cyanuric acid (CYA, also called stabilizer), and then asks whether the loss follows the sun, whether it continues overnight, and what the water looks like. Each path ends at a cause, the steps to confirm it, and the calculator or guide that sizes the fix. It cannot see your water, so confirm a result with a fresh test.

Worked example: a vinyl pool on trichlor tablets

An 18,000-gallon vinyl pool sits in full sun and has been fed trichlor tablets all season. A DPD test gives free chlorine of 1.5 ppm. A CYA test, which the owner had not run all summer, gives 80 ppm. The troubleshooter's path is CYA between 30 and 90 ppm, then a CYA-to-chlorine ratio above 45, because 80 divided by 1.5 is about 53.

The result is CYA too high for the chlorine level. CDC asks for at least 2 ppm free chlorine when the water holds CYA, and the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, flags a ratio above 45 to 1 as a hazard, so the reading of 1.5 ppm falls short on both counts. At 80 ppm CYA the ratio would need free chlorine of at least about 1.8 ppm, so the 2 ppm minimum is the one that governs. The tablet habit is the cause: each tablet of trichlor adds CYA along with the chlorine, and PHTA's cyanuric acid bulletin gives about 0.55 pounds of CYA for every pound of trichlor. The cyanuric acid calculator shows the chlorine floor and the share of water to replace.

Sunlight and stabilizer

PHTA states that without cyanuric acid in the water, bright sunlight can break down most of a pool's chlorine within an hour, and that 25 ppm of stabilizer slows the loss a great deal. Michigan State University Extension's manual describes the same effect in a different figure, with 97% of the chlorine lost in two hours of bright sun and a stabilized pool holding chlorine up to four times longer. PHTA gives 30 to 50 ppm as the ideal range when stabilizer is used, and no extra protection above 100 ppm. What cyanuric acid does explains the chemistry. Indoor pools have no sun to protect against, and PHTA does not recommend stabilizer for them.

Why too much CYA also looks like chlorine loss

CYA ties up chlorine in a reversible bond, so a high reading leaves less of the chlorine active. PHTA describes the effect as slowing disinfection and oxidation, and the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, advises raising free chlorine in proportion as CYA rises. Past 45 times the chlorine reading the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, treats the pool as a hazard, and it limits CYA to 90 ppm. Nothing you add removes CYA: PHTA lists a partial drain and refill, extra backwashing and routine water replacement.

What uses chlorine when the sun is not the cause

CDC lists swimmers' pee, sweat and dirt, sunlight, and splashing from hot tub jets among the things that reduce chlorine, and asks for tests at least twice a day, more often when the pool is busy. The tree separates three sinks. Algae raises chlorine demand, as Michigan State University Extension's manual notes, and a cloudy or green pool that loses chlorine overnight is feeding it; the green pool guide gives the order of work. Chloramines form when chlorine meets the nitrogen in swimmer waste, and the manual rates their sanitizing power at less than 1% of free chlorine's, so a pool with a lot of combined chlorine looks "used up." And a party, a storm or a pile of leaves can use a day's chlorine in an afternoon.

When the water is fine and the test is not

CDC says test strips are less accurate than a DPD kit, and that a sample above 10 ppm can bleach out and read low or zero. Michigan State University Extension's manual adds that tired reagents and a dirty viewing tube give unreliable readings. If CYA is in range, the water is clear and there is no smell, retest with a DPD kit from the same spot at the same time of day before concluding anything. Combined chlorine tells the rest: free chlorine subtracted from total chlorine, and the pool shock calculator sizes a breakpoint dose when it is high. The cloudiness side of that problem is in the cloudy water troubleshooter, and the smell side is in the chlorine smell troubleshooter.

What the tool cannot tell you

If CYA, chlorine, combined chlorine and the test are all in order and chlorine still falls by the evening, the loss may be in the equipment that feeds it, such as a feeder that is not delivering or a generator cell that is worn. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists feeder sizing and circulation among the things that set how much chlorine a pool needs to hold. The manufacturer's manual, or a pool service technician, is the next step. Write each reading and each dose down for a week first: a pattern of losses by hour is what a technician needs to see.