Pool Water Troubleshooter: Green, Cloudy, Smelly or Won't Hold Chlorine
Updated
What is wrong with your pool water?
Pick the symptom you can see or smell, answer one or two questions with a fresh DPD test in hand, and the tool names the likely cause and the page that goes deeper. It cannot see your water, so treat each answer as a lead to confirm by testing.
What is the first thing you notice?
The water is green
What does a DPD test show for free chlorine?
CDC sets the home-pool minimum at 1 ppm, or 2 ppm when the pool has CYA.
Below the minimum
Act now
Algae growing in under-chlorinated water
Green water with free chlorine below the minimum is algae winning against chlorine. Michigan State University Extension's manual describes free-floating green algae as the type chlorine controls most easily, once there is enough of it.
What to do
- Brush, shock, and run the filter continuously, in that order; the green pool guide gives the sequence.
- Size the shock dose with the shock calculator, which also covers breakpoint for combined chlorine.
- Retest after each dose.
At or above the minimum
Act now
Green water despite a chlorine reading
If chlorine reads fine and the water is still green, check CYA first. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says algae can need more free chlorine or a lower CYA-to-chlorine ratio, and PHTA notes that stabilizer reduces chlorine's kill rate. Michigan State University Extension's manual also lists green to reddish-brown water as algae or dissolved minerals, such as iron, copper and manganese.
What to do
- Test CYA; if CYA divided by free chlorine is over 45, raise chlorine or lower CYA.
- Brush surfaces and shock, then keep the filter running.
- If it clears and returns green or brown after shocking, have the water tested for metals.
I have not tested it
Deal with it soon
Test before you guess
Every cause in this tool is separated by a test: free chlorine, total chlorine (to get combined chlorine), pH, alkalinity and CYA. CDC advises a DPD kit over strips, and testing at least twice a day when the pool is in heavy use.
What to do
- Test free and total chlorine, pH, total alkalinity and CYA from one sample taken well below the surface and away from the returns.
- Return to this tool with the readings.
- Record them in the log so the next test has something to compare against.
The water is cloudy or hazy
Can you see the main drain at the bottom of the deep end?
No, I cannot see the bottom
Act now
Do not swim: the bottom is not visible
A pool you cannot see the bottom of is unsafe to swim in, because no one could spot a swimmer in trouble. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, lists a pool bottom that is not visible among its imminent health hazards.
What to do
- Keep everyone, children especially, out of the water until you can see the drain.
- Work through the cloudy water troubleshooter to find the cause; the color and a DPD test narrow it quickly.
- Run the pump continuously until the drain is clearly visible.
Yes, but the water looks hazy or milky
What does a DPD test show for free chlorine?
Below the minimum
Act now
Cloudy water with low chlorine
Low free chlorine lets organic matter and early algae build up, and it often goes with combined chlorine. Michigan State University Extension's manual calls breakpoint chlorination the way to remove the debris that causes cloudy water.
What to do
- Check combined chlorine; if it is above 0.4 ppm, shock to breakpoint.
- If combined chlorine is low, raise free chlorine and retest in a few hours.
- Run the filter continuously until the water clears.
At or above the minimum
Deal with it soon
Cloudy water with chlorine in range
When chlorine is fine, look at pH, alkalinity and the filter. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says high total alkalinity brings high pH, cloudy water and filter trouble, and Michigan State University Extension's manual says to clean or backwash a filter when the pressure rises by 10 to 12 psi or the water stays cloudy.
What to do
- Test pH and total alkalinity, and adjust alkalinity before pH.
- Check the filter's pressure and how long the pump runs each day.
- The cloudy water troubleshooter goes through each of these in turn.
A strong chlorine smell, red eyes or itchy skin
Subtract free chlorine from total chlorine. What is combined chlorine?
The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, sets 0.4 ppm as the level to act on.
More than 0.4 ppm
Act now
Chloramines
A sharp smell with combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm is chloramines, formed when chlorine meets sweat and urine. Michigan State University Extension's manual says they irritate eyes and mucous membranes and have under 1% of the sanitizing power of free chlorine. Too much chlorine is rarely the cause.
What to do
- Shock to breakpoint; the shock calculator sizes the dose.
- Shower before swimming and keep waste out of the water.
- The smell troubleshooter covers indoor pools and high pH as well.
0.4 ppm or less
Deal with it soon
The smell is not from chloramines
With combined chlorine low, the smell and irritation point elsewhere: free chlorine that is actually high (or a test bleaching out above 10 ppm), pH out of the 7.0 to 7.8 range, or chlorine too low to control organic matter.
What to do
- Compare free chlorine and pH with the CDC ranges.
- If the test color flashes and fades, dilute the sample before you add anything.
- The smell troubleshooter walks through each case.
I only tested free chlorine
Deal with it soon
Test before you guess
Every cause in this tool is separated by a test: free chlorine, total chlorine (to get combined chlorine), pH, alkalinity and CYA. CDC advises a DPD kit over strips, and testing at least twice a day when the pool is in heavy use.
What to do
- Test free and total chlorine, pH, total alkalinity and CYA from one sample taken well below the surface and away from the returns.
- Return to this tool with the readings.
- Record them in the log so the next test has something to compare against.
Chlorine will not hold
When does the free chlorine disappear?
Within hours on a sunny day, in a pool with little or no CYA
Act now
Sunlight is destroying the chlorine
PHTA says that without stabilizer, bright sunlight can break down most of a pool's chlorine within an hour, and that 25 ppm of cyanuric acid greatly slows this. PHTA's ideal range, when stabilizer is used, is 30 to 50 ppm.
What to do
- Test CYA, then add stabilizer if it is low; the cyanuric acid calculator sizes the dose.
- Test chlorine at least twice a day until it holds.
- The chlorine-keeps-dropping troubleshooter covers the other causes.
The pool has CYA, but chlorine still looks low for it
Act now
Too much stabilizer for the chlorine level
Stabilizer holds chlorine in reserve, so the more of it there is, the more free chlorine the pool needs. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, treats CYA above 45 times free chlorine as a hazard and sets 90 ppm as its ceiling for CYA.
What to do
- Divide CYA by free chlorine; raise chlorine until the ratio is 45 or less.
- Lower CYA by partial drain and refill, since nothing you add removes it.
- The cyanuric acid calculator shows the chlorine floor and the share of water to replace.
Overnight too, not only in the sun
Act now
Something is using the chlorine overnight
If chlorine falls with no sun on the water, something is using it up: algae, chloramines or a heavy swimmer and debris load. CDC lists swimmer waste and dirt among the things that reduce chlorine.
What to do
- Look for cloudiness, a green tint or slime on the walls.
- Check combined chlorine, and shock to breakpoint if it is above 0.4 ppm.
- The chlorine-keeps-dropping troubleshooter sorts the causes in order.
It's a salt pool and the generator isn't keeping up
Deal with it soon
Start with the salt cell itself
A salt chlorine generator only makes chlorine while water flows through a clean cell with enough salt in it. Its indicator lights say which of those is missing, and each brand's manual sets its own salt range and cold-water cutoff.
What to do
- Read the generator's lights or display before changing anything.
- Test salt with a separate kit, since the cell's own reading can drift.
- The salt cell troubleshooter walks through flow, salt, a scaled cell and cold water by brand.
Crust, scale or stains on surfaces
What do the marks look like?
White or grey crust on tile, at the waterline or in the equipment
Deal with it soon
Scale: calcium coming out of the water
Michigan State University Extension's manual describes scale forming on pool walls and inside plumbing when water is over-saturated with calcium carbonate, which can hurt equipment performance. High pH, high alkalinity, high calcium hardness and warm water all push in that direction, and PHTA's water balance bulletin explains the indexes that predict it.
What to do
- Test pH, alkalinity and calcium hardness, then run the saturation index.
- If the index is high, lower alkalinity, then pH; the order matters.
- Clean scale from a heater or chlorine generator cell as its manual directs.
Brown, black, green or rust-colored marks
Deal with it soon
Stains: usually minerals or corrosive water
Michigan State University Extension's manual lists stains on walls and floor as mineral deposits, and says brown, black or green water that stains surfaces is typical of under-saturated, aggressive water attacking metal parts. The remedy it gives is to adjust pH and alkalinity, add a sequestering agent, and drain, scrub and acid wash only if needed.
What to do
- Test pH, alkalinity and calcium hardness, and run the saturation index.
- Correct low pH or alkalinity first, since aggressive water keeps pulling metal into the pool.
- Have a pool service technician identify the metal before you treat the stain.
In short: Most pool water problems come down to a few readings: free chlorine against CDC's 1 ppm (2 ppm with CYA), combined chlorine against the MAHC 2024's 0.4 ppm action level in a public-pool code, and CYA. This hub asks about green, cloudy, smell, chlorine loss or deposits, then sends you to the detailed troubleshooter.
This troubleshooter narrows down likely causes from published guidance; it can't see or test your water. Retest before you add anything, follow the label on every product you use, and call a pool service technician or a licensed electrician for anything electrical, gas-fired or structural.
Get new tools by email
When we add a tool to Pool Chemical Log, we'll send you one short email. Nothing else.
This is the front door for pool water problems. It is for a home pool owner who can see or smell that something is wrong but does not yet know whether it is chlorine, pH, stabilizer or the filter. Choose the symptom that comes first, answer one or two questions from a DPD test, and the tool gives a short diagnosis with the pages that go further: three detailed troubleshooters, the green pool guide and the calculators that size a dose. It cannot see your water, so treat each answer as a lead to confirm with a test.
Worked example: a hazy pool with a faint smell
A pool that was clear last week now looks hazy, and the owner can still make out the drain at the deep end. A DPD test gives free chlorine of 0.5 ppm and total chlorine of 1.4 ppm, so combined chlorine is 0.9 ppm. The hub's path is cloudy or hazy, then the main drain visible, then free chlorine below the minimum.
The result is cloudy water with low chlorine. CDC puts the home-pool minimum at 1 ppm, or 2 ppm when the water holds CYA, so 0.5 ppm is under it, and combined chlorine of 0.9 ppm is more than twice the 0.4 ppm the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, says to act on. Michigan State University Extension's manual calls breakpoint chlorination the way to remove the debris behind cloudy water, and the pool shock calculator sizes that dose from the combined chlorine reading. The next click is the cloudy water troubleshooter, which checks pH, alkalinity and the filter once chlorine is back up.
The five starting points
Green. Green water is almost always algae, and the question that splits it is free chlorine. Under the minimum, chlorine is losing to algae and the answer is in the green pool guide. With a normal chlorine reading, look at CYA: the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says algae can need a higher free chlorine or a lower CYA-to-chlorine ratio, and Michigan State University Extension's manual lists green to reddish-brown water as algae or dissolved minerals.
Cloudy. If the bottom of the deep end is not visible, the pool is closed to swimmers. The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, lists that condition as an imminent health hazard, and the same sense applies to a backyard pool. Otherwise the next question is again free chlorine, and the detailed tool takes it from there.
A strong chlorine smell, red eyes or itchy skin. Combined chlorine, which is total minus free chlorine, separates chloramines from everything else. Michigan State University Extension's manual says they irritate the eyes and sanitize far less than free chlorine does, which is why a smelly pool often needs more chlorine, not less. The chlorine smell troubleshooter covers the other causes.
Chlorine will not hold. PHTA's cyanuric acid bulletin says unstabilized chlorine can be mostly gone within an hour of bright sun, and CDC lists swimmer waste, dirt and sunlight among the things that reduce chlorine. The hub asks when the chlorine disappears, since sun-only loss, loss that also happens overnight and a pool with plenty of CYA each point to a different cause. The chlorine-keeps-dropping troubleshooter goes through them in order.
Crust, scale or stains. The manual describes scale forming on walls and inside plumbing when water is over-saturated with calcium carbonate, and mineral deposits and metal-colored stains when water is aggressive. PHTA's water balance bulletin explains the indexes used to predict which way a pool is leaning, and the pool LSI calculator computes one. This branch gives a first lead only; identifying a particular stain is beyond what a pool-water test can do.
Why the hub starts with a test
Every branch above splits on a number, not on how the water looks. Free chlorine, combined chlorine, pH, alkalinity and CYA decide where a symptom leads, and a single missing reading can send the diagnosis the wrong way. CDC recommends a DPD kit over strips and testing at least twice a day, more often when the pool is busy. It also warns that a sample above 10 ppm can bleach out and read low or zero, so a pool that smells strongly and tests zero needs a diluted sample, not a dose. The tool's "I have not tested" answers all lead to the same step: test first.
What the hub does not do
It does not name a dose. The detailed troubleshooters and the calculators do that, because a dose depends on the pool's volume, the product's strength and the label. It does not replace a visit when equipment is involved, such as a pump that will not prime, a heater with scale or a salt system that has stopped producing. For those, a pool service technician or a licensed electrician is the right call. The ideal levels chart on this site lists every target in one place, with CDC's home-pool figures beside the public-pool code's.
Sources (6)
- CDC, Home Pool and Hot Tub Water Treatment and Testing cdc.gov
- CDC, Model Aquatic Health Code, 2024 (5th edition): Code, a public-pool code cdc.gov
- CDC, Model Aquatic Health Code, 2024 (5th edition): Annex, guidance for public pools cdc.gov
- Michigan State University Extension, Swimming Pool Pest Management, Category 5A manual canr.msu.edu
- PHTA, Cyanuric Acid technical bulletin phta.org
- PHTA, Water Balance Indexes technical bulletin phta.org