Pool Stain Identifier: Iron, Copper, Scale or Algae? By Colour and Location
Updated
Pool stain identifier
For a stain or water tint on plaster, vinyl, fiberglass or tile. Answer by colour and place to find the likely cause: a dissolved metal, scale, corrosive water or something living. Test before you treat; a colour alone is a clue, not proof.
What colour is the stain or water tint?
Look at it in daylight, and note whether it is on the surface or in it.
Rust, orange or reddish brown
Deal with it soon
Rust and reddish brown point to dissolved iron
The MSU Extension manual says dissolved iron is responsible for staining and color problems in pool water and on its surfaces, and that an iron test kit gives brown to red colors when iron is present. Iron comes from the fill water or from corroding pipes, tanks and equipment. When minerals come out of solution they form stains on the walls and floor.
What to do
- Test for iron with a kit, and note when it is in the water, not just on the surface.
- Ask where the iron comes from: test the fill water, and look at metal equipment and fittings for corrosion.
- MSU says to keep chlorine adequate, since chlorine helps iron come out of solution so the filter can remove it, and to add a sequestering agent, which keeps minerals dissolved instead of letting them settle on surfaces.
- Bring pH and total alkalinity in line first. If the stains remain, MSU's last step is to drain, scrub and acid wash, and the surface maker's advice should come before any acid.
- Run the saturation index: corrosive water pulls more iron out of metal.
Blue or blue-green, or hair and nails turning green
Deal with it soon
Blue or green stains and green hair point to copper
MSU says copper in pool water stains the walls, tints the water and turns hair or fingernail cuticles green or blue, and its recommended copper level is 0 ppm. Sources of copper are corroding metal equipment and plumbing, copper-based algaecides and silver-copper ionizers. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, warns that a copper algaecide stains when pH is poorly controlled, and that copper-based algaecides should not be used with an ionizer, which already adds copper.
What to do
- Test for copper; most kits turn blue or green when it is present. If a calcium hardness test never changes color, MSU says copper is the likely interference.
- Stop using a copper-based algaecide, and check an ionizer against its maker's procedure and recommended copper range.
- MSU says a pH of 7.2 to 7.3 and a hardness of 350 ppm reduce copper's bad effects on the surface.
- Check pipes, tanks and other metal equipment for corrosion as the source of the metal, and fix the water balance that caused it.
- Use a sequestering agent or metal remover, following its label. If a stain survives, ask a pool service technician before using an acid.
Black or very dark brown spots
Does the pool have a silver-copper ionizer, and do the spots stay when you scrub them?
Scrub a spot first with a stiff brush that suits your surface.
Yes, there is a silver-copper ionizer
Deal with it soon
Black spots on a pool with an ionizer
MSU lists black spots on pool surfaces as the result when a silver-copper ionizer runs without the right water chemistry. The ionizer adds copper and silver by electrolysis, so the same rules as for copper apply, and MSU adds that a chemical disinfectant must run alongside it.
What to do
- Test copper and pH, and compare the readings with the ionizer maker's range.
- Keep a chlorine residual as well; an ionizer doesn't replace it.
- Follow the ionizer maker's procedure for bringing copper back into range.
- Get the water balanced before trying to clean the spots, or they come back.
No ionizer, and the spots stay put when scrubbed
Deal with it soon
Dark stains around metal usually mean corrosive water
The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says a low pH can raise the rate of metal corrosion, and that aggressive water can dissolve plaster and metal parts such as handrails, ladders and light fixtures, and leave stains on the walls and floor. MSU adds that brown, black or green water is typical of under-saturated water attacking metal components of the circulation system. CDC says the pipes are more likely to corrode when pH is under 7.0. Stains form when that dissolved metal comes out of solution onto the surface.
What to do
- Test pH, total alkalinity and calcium hardness, and run the saturation index. The Annex calls an index under -0.3 corrosive.
- The Annex says an index can be brought into the -0.3 to +0.3 range with a pH of 7.2 to 7.6, alkalinity of 60 to 180 ppm and calcium hardness of 200 to 400 ppm in masonry or 80 to 200 ppm in vinyl or fiberglass.
- PHTA warns that saturation indexes don't fully predict metal corrosion, which is mostly a matter of pH, dissolved salts and oxidizers. Check for corrosion even with a good index.
- Test the water for metals, including iron and copper, so you know which one you are dealing with. MSU also names manganese, but gives no stain color for it.
- Replace corroded fittings; chemistry can stop new stains but doesn't repair worn metal.
No ionizer, and the spots scrape or scrub away
Deal with it soon
Patches that scrub off and keep returning are probably algae
MSU describes three kinds of algae: green, black and yellow. Black and yellow algae attach to walls, floors and steps and are very hard to remove once attached. Yellow algae can be brushed off. Black algae needs a stainless steel brush, which scores the cell wall so chlorine can reach it. Algae also raise the chlorine demand and leave surfaces slippery.
What to do
- Brush the patch hard, and note whether it comes off. On vinyl or fiberglass use only a brush the surface's maker allows.
- Bring free chlorine up and keep it there; the green pool guide gives the order.
- Use an algaecide made for the type you have, per its label, with the brushing. MSU says brushing is necessary alongside it.
- If a spot doesn't come off with brushing, it is less likely to be algae; try the metals branch.
White, grey or light tan, rough or crusty to the touch
Deal with it soon
White or light, rough, crusty patches are scale
The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, describes scale as white or lightly colored rough blotches on the walls that also coats the piping, filter system and other objects, and that appears when the saturation index is above +0.3. The index rises with temperature, total alkalinity, pH and calcium hardness. MSU names calcium as the only hardness ion that forms scale, and says scale shows up in heaters and on plaster. PHTA says a slight layer is less harmful than corrosion, which does permanent damage.
What to do
- Test pH, alkalinity and calcium hardness, then run the saturation index.
- If the index is high, bring down whichever readings are out of line, alkalinity before pH.
- MSU's fix for mineral deposits is to adjust pH and alkalinity, add a sequestering agent, and if necessary drain, scrub and acid wash the surface.
- Scale also builds up on heater coils and heat exchangers, so it is worth checking the equipment too.
- Retest monthly, since scale returns when the balance drifts.
Green, yellow or dark patches that sit on the surface
Where is it?
Under or beside leaves, mulch or other debris, or in a shaded corner
Keep an eye on it
Dark patches under debris: the sources name leaves but give no remover
MSU's closing instructions say to remove leaves and other debris to prevent staining, so leaves left on a surface are a recognized cause. None of the saved sources describe how to remove a leaf stain, so there is no tested method to quote.
What to do
- Vacuum and skim the debris promptly, and brush the stained spot.
- If the stain fades with brushing, it was organic. If it doesn't, treat it as a metal or scale stain and test for iron, copper and calcium.
- Ask the surface maker or a pool service technician about a stain remover for your surface type before using any product.
- Skim promptly whenever leaves fall.
Slimy or slippery on the walls and floor, with greenish water
Deal with it soon
Patches that scrub off and keep returning are probably algae
MSU describes three kinds of algae: green, black and yellow. Black and yellow algae attach to walls, floors and steps and are very hard to remove once attached. Yellow algae can be brushed off. Black algae needs a stainless steel brush, which scores the cell wall so chlorine can reach it. Algae also raise the chlorine demand and leave surfaces slippery.
What to do
- Brush the patch hard, and note whether it comes off. On vinyl or fiberglass use only a brush the surface's maker allows.
- Bring free chlorine up and keep it there; the green pool guide gives the order.
- Use an algaecide made for the type you have, per its label, with the brushing. MSU says brushing is necessary alongside it.
- If a spot doesn't come off with brushing, it is less likely to be algae; try the metals branch.
Around a metal ladder, rail, light, skimmer or drain
Deal with it soon
Dark stains around metal usually mean corrosive water
The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says a low pH can raise the rate of metal corrosion, and that aggressive water can dissolve plaster and metal parts such as handrails, ladders and light fixtures, and leave stains on the walls and floor. MSU adds that brown, black or green water is typical of under-saturated water attacking metal components of the circulation system. CDC says the pipes are more likely to corrode when pH is under 7.0. Stains form when that dissolved metal comes out of solution onto the surface.
What to do
- Test pH, total alkalinity and calcium hardness, and run the saturation index. The Annex calls an index under -0.3 corrosive.
- The Annex says an index can be brought into the -0.3 to +0.3 range with a pH of 7.2 to 7.6, alkalinity of 60 to 180 ppm and calcium hardness of 200 to 400 ppm in masonry or 80 to 200 ppm in vinyl or fiberglass.
- PHTA warns that saturation indexes don't fully predict metal corrosion, which is mostly a matter of pH, dissolved salts and oxidizers. Check for corrosion even with a good index.
- Test the water for metals, including iron and copper, so you know which one you are dealing with. MSU also names manganese, but gives no stain color for it.
- Replace corroded fittings; chemistry can stop new stains but doesn't repair worn metal.
In short: Rust and reddish brown point to dissolved iron, blue-green to copper, white rough patches to scale (an index above +0.3, per the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools) and dark patches round metal to corrosive water (below -0.3).
This troubleshooter narrows down likely causes from published guidance; it can't see or test your water. Retest before you add anything, follow the label on every product you use, and call a pool service technician or a licensed electrician for anything electrical, gas-fired or structural.
Handling pool chemicals safely
In the words of the public-health agencies:
Chemicals shall be added to water when diluting as opposed to adding water to a concentrated chemical.
(MAHC 2024, 5.9.3.4.2.2 (a public-pool code) (PDF, opens in a new tab))Two or more chemicals shall never be mixed in the same dilution water.
(MAHC 2024, 5.9.3.4.2.3.1 (a public-pool code) (PDF, opens in a new tab))If label directs pre-dissolving, add the pool chemical to water. NEVER add water to the pool chemical because a violent (potentially explosive) reaction can occur.
(CDC, Use Pool Chemicals Safely (PDF, opens in a new tab))Store each pool chemical separately in a dedicated location.
(CDC, Pool Chemical Safety (opens in a new tab))Do not mix old chemicals with fresh chemical, even if they are the same type
(EPA 550-F-01-003 (PDF, opens in a new tab))Never mix:
(CDC, Use Pool Chemicals Safely (PDF, opens in a new tab))Chlorine products with acid; this could create toxic gases.
Different pool chemicals (for example, different types of chlorine products) with each other or with any other substance.
Get new tools by email
When we add a tool to Pool Chemical Log, we'll send you one short email. Nothing else.
A stain on pool plaster, vinyl or tile has a short list of possible causes: a dissolved metal that has settled out, corrosive water that is eating metal parts, a mineral crust of scale, or something alive such as algae. This tool narrows that list from two things anyone can see, the colour and the place. It is for a home pool owner who has noticed a mark and wants to know what to test before reaching for a product. The metal causes and fixes come from the Michigan State University Extension pool manual. The water balance figures come from the CDC's Model Aquatic Health Code Annex, guidance for public pools, and from PHTA's bulletin on saturation indexes.
Worked example: dark spots around a ladder in a plaster pool
A 15,000-gallon plaster pool develops dark brown spots around the ladder anchors and the rim of the light niche, and they don't scrub away. There is no ionizer on the pool. The latest test reads pH 6.9, total alkalinity 60 ppm, calcium hardness 150 ppm and CYA 30 ppm, with the water at 80°F.
The tree starts at colour, black or very dark brown, then asks about an ionizer (none) and whether the spots scrub off (they don't). That lands on corrosive water. The numbers agree: the pool LSI calculator gives an index of −1.00 for those readings, far below the −0.3 that the MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, calls corrosive. CDC's home pool page says that when pH falls under 7.0, the pipes are "more likely to corrode or break down", and this pool is at 6.9.
The fix starts with the water, not the stain. Raising alkalinity to 90 ppm, pH to 7.4 and calcium hardness to 250 ppm, with CYA unchanged, puts the same calculator at 0.00. The dark spots are dissolved metal that has come out of solution onto the plaster, and no cleaner will hold them off while the water stays aggressive. The tree also asks you to test for metals, so the actual metal is known before anything is bought.
Colour and place, in practice
- Rust, orange or reddish brown points first to iron. MSU says an iron test kit shows brown to red colours, and that dissolved iron is responsible for staining and colour problems in the water and on surfaces.
- Blue, blue-green, or hair that turns green points to copper. MSU says copper stains the walls, tints the water and turns hair or nail cuticles green or blue.
- Black or dark brown spots have three candidates. Black spots follow when a silver-copper ionizer runs outside the right chemistry. Black algae is the second. A third is metal from corrosion, when the spots sit around a ladder, rail, light or drain.
- White, grey or light tan crust is scale, a mineral deposit rather than a stain.
- Green, yellow or dark patches that scrub off are biological.
Metals: iron, copper and the others
Two metals have a clear signature in the sources. Iron shows as rust or reddish brown, and copper as blue or green. MSU also lists manganese, along with iron, copper and algae, among the things to check when the water is green to reddish brown, but it gives no stain colour for manganese, so a dark stain with no ionizer and no black algae is a reason to test rather than a diagnosis.
MSU's treatments are consistent. Adequate chlorine helps iron come out of solution so that the filter removes it. A sequestering agent holds minerals in solution instead of letting them settle on the walls and floor, and MSU says pools with high iron need one as part of routine treatment. For copper, MSU recommends a level of 0 ppm, and says that a pH of 7.2 to 7.3 with a hardness of 350 ppm limits the damage. If the stain remains, MSU's last resort for mineral deposits is to drain, scrub and acid wash, and the surface maker's advice should come before any acid.
Copper often arrives by choice. The Annex, guidance for public pools, warns that copper-based algaecides stain when pH is poorly controlled, and says they should not be used on a pool with a copper ionizer, which already adds copper.
Corrosive water is how metals get in
The same Annex, guidance for public pools, says a low pH can raise the rate of metal corrosion, and that water with a low index can cause "etching, pitting, dissolving, and staining of walls, grouting, and plumbing". MSU adds that brown, black or green water is typical of under-saturated water attacking metal parts of the circulation system. Low calcium hardness and low alkalinity push the same way.
One nuance matters. PHTA warns that the saturation indexes don't fully predict the corrosion of metals, which depends more on pH, dissolved salts and oxidizers. Water can be corrosive to metals and still sit inside the index range. If metal parts are pitting, treat that as a problem of its own even when the index looks fine. The ideal levels chart lists the ranges to aim for.
Scale is a deposit, not a stain
The Annex, guidance for public pools, describes scale as "white or lightly colored rough blotches" on the walls, and says it forms on piping and in the filter system too. It appears when the index runs high, and the index rises with temperature, alkalinity, pH and calcium hardness. MSU points out that only calcium forms scale, not magnesium. PHTA treats a thin layer as less harmful than corrosion, which does permanent damage, so the aim is balance rather than zero. The usual fix is to bring alkalinity down first and then pH, using the pH and alkalinity calculator.
Algae and leaves
MSU describes three kinds of algae by colour: green, black and yellow. Black and yellow attach to surfaces and are hard to remove once they do. Yellow comes off with brushing; black needs a stainless steel brush that scores its outer wall so that chlorine can reach it. Leaves are the other organic cause, and MSU's advice is to remove them before they stain. No saved source gives a method for removing a leaf stain, so the tool says so instead of guessing. For algae, the green pool guide gives the order of work.
When to get help
A stain that returns after the water is balanced, metal that is visibly pitting, or a pool with well water of unknown iron content is worth a visit from a pool service technician with a full water analysis. Keep each test in the pool chemistry log, so a pattern, such as pH slipping after every rain, is visible.
Sources (4)
- Michigan State University Extension, Swimming Pool Pest Management, Category 5A manual canr.msu.edu
- CDC, Model Aquatic Health Code, 2024 (5th edition): Annex, guidance for public pools cdc.gov
- PHTA, Water Balance Indexes technical bulletin phta.org
- CDC, Home Pool and Hot Tub Water Treatment and Testing cdc.gov