Pool Smells Like Chlorine Troubleshooter: Chloramines, Red Eyes and Itchy Skin
Updated
Why does my pool smell so strongly of chlorine?
The sharp smell and the stinging eyes that people blame on too much chlorine usually come from the opposite: chlorine that has already combined with swimmer waste. Only a test that reads both free and total chlorine can tell the two apart, so start with one.
What test did you run?
A DPD kit with a total chlorine reagent reads free and total chlorine. Combined chlorine is total minus free. Plain strips and many basic kits read free chlorine only.
A DPD test of both free and total chlorine
What is combined chlorine, total minus free?
The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, sets 0.4 ppm as the level at which to act. Michigan State University Extension's manual uses a lower trigger of 0.2 ppm.
More than 0.4 ppm
What is the free chlorine?
CDC gives 1 ppm as the minimum for a pool, or 2 ppm if the pool has CYA.
Below the minimum
Act now
Chloramines and not enough free chlorine
High combined chlorine with low free chlorine is the classic chloramine pool. The MAHC 2024 glossary, a public-pool code, explains that chlorine added to water with ammonia from urine and sweat first forms monochloramine and then dichloramine, and that adding free chlorine at about 10 times the combined chlorine carries the compounds through breakpoint and removes the odors and eye irritation.
What to do
- Shock to breakpoint with the pool shock calculator, which sizes the dose at 10 times your combined chlorine reading.
- Add the whole dose at once with the pump running, and keep swimmers out until free chlorine has fallen back to the normal range.
- Retest free and total chlorine the next day; if combined chlorine is still above 0.4 ppm, repeat.
At or above the minimum
Is the pool indoors, or in an enclosed room?
Yes, the smell hangs in the air in the room
Act now
Chloramines escaping into the air
The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says trichloramine has the most effect on air quality of the chloramines because it leaves the water easily, and that it is an irritant to the eyes, nose and throat. The same Annex says CDC has investigated skin, eye and breathing complaints in indoor venues that could be tied to chloramines in the air.
What to do
- Shock to breakpoint with the pool shock calculator and keep people out of the room until the smell fades.
- Cut the supply of waste: shower before swimming, and keep swimmers from urinating in the water.
- Ask a pool service technician about the room's ventilation, and about ozone or ultraviolet treatment, which the Annex says might destroy inorganic chloramines.
No, it is outdoors
Deal with it soon
Chloramines: shock to breakpoint
Free chlorine is fine and combined chlorine is over 0.4 ppm, so swimmers have loaded the pool with chloramines faster than normal chlorine clears them. Michigan State University Extension's manual puts the combined chlorine trigger at 0.2 ppm and calls breakpoint chlorination the accepted way to remove them.
What to do
- Shock to breakpoint with the pool shock calculator, which sizes the dose at 10 times your combined chlorine reading.
- Check whether your fill water is chloraminated. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says a municipal supply that uses chloramines can bring some into the pool.
- Retest the next day, and record the combined chlorine reading each week to catch it early.
0.4 ppm or less
What is the free chlorine?
Above 4 ppm
Act now
Free chlorine is actually high
The smell here is real chlorine. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, says EPA has approved no pool product for use above 4 ppm with bathers present, and the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, treats free chlorine above 10 ppm with bathers present as an imminent hazard.
What to do
- Stop adding chlorine and keep swimmers out until free chlorine is back in range.
- Let it fall on its own; CDC lists sunlight among the things that use chlorine up.
- Check the product label for its upper limit before the next dose, and retest.
At or above the minimum, up to 4 ppm
What is the pH?
Above 7.8
Deal with it soon
pH is high
CDC says chlorine kills germs less well as pH rises, especially above 8.0. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, cites one study in which eye irritation did not change across pH 7.0 to 9.0 and chloramines or high chlorine were the main drivers, so pH is rarely the whole story. It still weakens your chlorine, which lets chloramines build up.
What to do
- Lower alkalinity first if it is above 180 ppm, then pH, in small doses with a retest between.
- Once pH is back in range, retest combined chlorine.
- If the smell and the irritation return, shock to breakpoint.
7.0 to 7.8
Keep an eye on it
The chemistry looks normal
With free chlorine in range, combined chlorine low and pH between 7.0 and 7.8, the test kit finds nothing wrong. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, notes that a standard test measures all combined chlorine together, so two pools with the same reading can differ in how much irritating inorganic chloramine they hold.
What to do
- Retest with fresh reagents at a different spot in the pool, away from the returns.
- Rinse thoroughly after swimming and shower before, since waste on swimmers drives chloramine formation.
- If irritation continues with normal readings, take a sample to a pool supply store or a pool service technician for a full analysis.
Below 7.0
Deal with it soon
pH is low
Michigan State University Extension's manual lists red eyes, hair loss, staining, equipment damage and cloudy water for low pH. CDC says low pH makes pipes more likely to corrode, even though chlorine works better.
What to do
- Test total alkalinity, since low alkalinity is the usual reason pH will not stay up.
- Raise alkalinity first, then pH, in small doses with a retest between.
- Retest after swimming and record the readings in the log.
Below the minimum
Deal with it soon
Low free chlorine and little combined chlorine
If free chlorine is under the minimum and the test finds few chloramines, the smell may come from something the test cannot see: organic matter, early algae or a sample that is not representative. Michigan State University Extension's manual lists a disagreeable odor or taste among the effects of algae.
What to do
- Raise free chlorine into the normal range and retest after a few hours.
- Look for cloudiness, green tint or slime on the walls and steps.
- If chlorine will not hold, work through the chlorine-keeps-dropping troubleshooter.
Only free chlorine, or a strip
Deal with it soon
Test total chlorine before changing anything
A free chlorine reading cannot tell too much chlorine from chloramines. Michigan State University Extension's manual says that if the free and total readings are the same but swimmers still complain of red eyes and strong odors, a chloramine problem is still possible, and a leftover reagent in the tube can cause a false match.
What to do
- Use a DPD kit that reads total chlorine as well as free chlorine, and subtract free from total.
- Rinse the viewing tube thoroughly between tests.
- Come back to this troubleshooter with both readings.
The color flashes and fades, or the test reads 0
Act now
A very high chlorine level can look like zero
CDC warns that when chlorine is above 10 ppm the test can bleach out and show a false low or a reading of 0. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, notes that operators have kept adding chlorine without realizing the test was bleaching out. A strong smell with a vanishing test color is a reason to stop adding chlorine.
What to do
- Add no more chlorine. Dilute a fresh sample with a known amount of tap water, test it, and multiply by the dilution.
- If the real reading is above 10 ppm, keep swimmers out; the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, counts that level with bathers present as an imminent hazard.
- Retest every few hours until free chlorine is back near the normal range.
In short: A sharp chlorine smell with red eyes usually means chloramines, not too much chlorine. Total chlorine minus free chlorine gives combined chlorine, and the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, sets 0.4 ppm as the level to act on. This tool also checks for high chlorine, a bleached-out test and pH.
This troubleshooter narrows down likely causes from published guidance; it can't see or test your water. Retest before you add anything, follow the label on every product you use, and call a pool service technician or a licensed electrician for anything electrical, gas-fired or structural.
Get new tools by email
When we add a tool to Pool Chemical Log, we'll send you one short email. Nothing else.
This troubleshooter is for anyone who walks up to a pool and is hit by a strong chemical smell, or climbs out with red eyes and itchy skin, and wonders whether to add less chlorine or more. It asks what test you ran, then for combined chlorine and free chlorine, and ends at one of ten results: chloramines with low or adequate chlorine, chloramines in the air of an indoor pool, chlorine that really is high, a test that is bleaching out, a pH problem, or a pool whose readings look normal. It cannot smell your pool, so retest before acting.
Worked example: after a birthday party
A 20,000-gallon outdoor vinyl pool hosted a dozen children on Saturday, and by Sunday morning it smells sharp and several swimmers complain their eyes sting. A DPD test shows free chlorine of 2.0 ppm, total chlorine of 3.1 ppm and pH 7.6, and the pool holds CYA, so CDC's 2 ppm minimum applies. Combined chlorine is total minus free, which is 1.1 ppm.
The path is a DPD test of both, then combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm, then free chlorine at the minimum, then an outdoor pool. The result is chloramines, with a shock to breakpoint. The MAHC 2024 glossary, a public-pool code, puts breakpoint at free chlorine added at about 10 times the combined chlorine, here about 11 ppm of new free chlorine. The pool shock calculator works out the product amount for the pool's volume. The pool will then read well above 10 ppm, the level the MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, treats as an imminent hazard with bathers present, so it stays closed until free chlorine falls back to the normal range.
Why the smell is not the chlorine
The chloramine smell is a by-product of chlorine doing its job. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, explains that chloramines form when free chlorine combines with compounds in sweat and urine, and that they leave the water as gas, causing strong odors and irritation to the eyes, mucous membranes and skin. Michigan State University Extension's manual makes the same point in plainer terms: chloramines carry an unpleasant odor, irritate the eyes, and have under 1% of the sanitizing power of free chlorine. A pool that reeks and stings is, in most cases, short of working chlorine rather than full of it.
The action level, and what it is not
The MAHC 2024, a public-pool code, asks the operator to act on combined chlorine above 0.4 ppm, by superchlorinating, replacing water or improving swimmer hygiene. Its Annex, guidance for public pools, is candid that 0.4 ppm is an action level and not an absolute limit, chosen because a standard test lumps irritating inorganic chloramines together with organic compounds whose health effects are less clear. Michigan State University Extension's manual sets its own lower trigger of 0.2 ppm. Neither figure is a rule for a backyard pool. Both are reasonable points at which to shock, and the lower the reading, the less there is to smell.
When the chlorine really is high
The opposite problem exists but is less common. If free chlorine is far above the normal range, the smell is real chlorine. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, notes that EPA has not approved any pool product for use above 4 ppm with bathers present. Above 10 ppm, CDC warns the DPD test can bleach out and show a false low or zero, and the Annex describes operators who kept adding chlorine because the test showed little. A strong smell with a color that flashes and fades is a signal to stop adding chlorine, dilute the sample and measure again.
pH, eyes and skin
CDC keeps pH between 7.0 and 7.8 and says chlorine kills germs less well as pH rises. Michigan State University Extension's manual lists red eyes and hair loss for low pH and irritation to users for high pH. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, cites a study in which eye irritation did not change across pH 7.0 to 9.0, so pH is usually a contributor and seldom the cause. If pH is off, the guide to lowering pH gives the order of work, with alkalinity first.
Reducing the load
Shocking removes chloramines that have formed; it does not stop new ones. The MAHC Annex, guidance for public pools, lists showering, not urinating in the water, effective filtration and replacing some water as the ways to reduce the contaminants that form them, and notes that a municipal supply treated with chloramines can bring some into the pool. An indoor pool needs more attention, because trichloramine has the most effect on air quality, and ozone or ultraviolet treatment might destroy inorganic chloramines. Ask a pool service technician about the room's ventilation and about secondary treatment.
When to get help
If readings are normal and the irritation persists, test again with fresh reagents at a different spot, then take a sample to a pool supply store or a pool service technician. Persistent breathing symptoms among swimmers or people on the deck deserve a doctor's attention rather than another dose of chemicals. For the other side of this problem, the chlorine-keeps-dropping troubleshooter covers chlorine that will not hold, and the cloudy water troubleshooter covers a pool that smells and looks off. The ideal levels chart lists each target in one place.
Sources (4)
- CDC, Home Pool and Hot Tub Water Treatment and Testing cdc.gov
- CDC, Model Aquatic Health Code, 2024 (5th edition): Code, a public-pool code cdc.gov
- CDC, Model Aquatic Health Code, 2024 (5th edition): Annex, guidance for public pools cdc.gov
- Michigan State University Extension, Swimming Pool Pest Management, Category 5A manual canr.msu.edu